Establish consequences for breaking
rules. "Rules were made to be broken," goes an
old saying, and they get broken at home as often as anywhere
else--even those rules that rest on strong agreement. When this
happens, kids must pay consequences, or else they learn that
your rules mean nothing.
There are three types of consequences, only two of which help
to build character. See if you can pick them out.
- Natural Consequences. Allowing events to simply run
their course. Example: getting cold on a winter day when you
forgot to wear a coat.
- Logical Consequences. Forfeiting a privilege until
responsibilities are met. Example: allowing a young person to
go out only after chores are done, and denying this privilege
(not a right) until chores are done.
- Arbitrary Consequences. Relying on inflicting pain
and fear and often unrelated to any established rule. Example:
spanking a cranky kid who doesn't know what to do about his or
her bad mood.
As you probably already guessed, only natural and logical
consequences really teach lessons-or, at least, positive lessons
worth learning and which translate into character.
Natural consequences are the best teachers of discipline,
and we should let our kids experience them when to do so will
not endanger their health or inconvenience others.
No parent wants a toddler to learn that crossing a street
alone is dangerous by allowing a car to teach the lesson. Nor
do we want our teenagers to learn the hazards of drug use by
allowing them to get strung out on crystal meth. But we should
let them take as many lumps and bruises from life as possible;
they'll learn from these.
The principle behind logical consequences is that privileges
must be earned and maintained through responsible action. This
is, after all, the way most of the world works most of the time.
A toddler can understand that she can't play with a second
toy until the first has been picked up, or that she can't come
out of your home "whine room" until the whining stops
and she is ready to relate without being cranky. Similarly, teenagers
can respect the fact that they're going to get grounded if they
stay out past curfew. If possible, try to link consequences to
privileges to maximize the lessons that kids can learn.
If you and your kids can agree on what consequences will be
experienced when rules are broken, your kids then have a choice:
Keep the rules or experience the consequences.
You are thus removed from the role of the "heavy;"
and instead become the person who sees to it that their decisions
are honored. Then kids will be less likely to blame parents for
their poor choices. Then, too, will they learn to become more
responsible for their own behavior.
Be consistent. Everything
we've talked about thus far takes time, effort, and lots of involvement
with our kids. still, there's a payoff: If we're consistent in
our affirmation and discipline, our kids won't be as defiant
and hard to get along with.
On the other hand, if we're not consistent in clarifying rules
or in allowing kids to experience the consequences of their choices,
they'll almost certainly be worse off for it and so will we.
Like trees that go unpruned, children that grow up without
consistency often grow out of control, dissipating themselves
and bearing little fruit. They need (and actually want) our consistency
and guidance so they might experience a strong, stable point
of reference for growth.
Consistency is one of the greatest gifts we can give our kids,
provided it doesn't turn into rigidity.